Sunday 2 November 2014

The Barking Dog by Cordelia Strube

Sometimes, life brings us hopeless situations. While we all have our challenges, some have a lot more  than others.  Cordelia Strube's The Barking Dog drags us into a world that is plagued by hardship and sorrow.

Maybe it was THIS dog that was barking?!?

Greer Pentland is a middle aged mother and wife is struggling with countless challenges. She is buried in sorrowful circumstances. Here is an abbreviated list of the miseries afflicting the central protagonist:

-She's a Realtor (ok, that's not really a misery but I had to laugh, as we have something in common...)
-She has breast cancer
-Her son is a social recluse who is suffering from untreated depression and OCD
-Her son is also on trial for murdering 2 of his neighbours in his sleep
-Her ex-husband is constantly picking fights with her
-Her live-in aunt constantly argues with her son, and refuses a much needed pacemaker
-Her son runs over a cat while driving and refuses to drive again
-Her only friend has a speech impediment that makes him almost impossible to understand
-The girl next door, who is schizophrenic and in crisis is unable to cope with her circumstances
 Author and Teacher Cordelia Strube
-Her son kills himself in a car crash
-She kills herself.

Darker than dark, the complete absence of light is how I would summarize this novel. But I must stress that this novel is well written. The characters are well developed. The story is very depression though...like watching a train wreck in slow motion.

Now, here's what's interesting for me on a personal level. About 3 years ago while brushing my teeth and getting the lunch boxes sorted, I heard Cordelia Strube interviewed on CBC's Metro Morning. She was promoting the Creative Writing courses at Ryerson University as one of the instructors. Early that morning, one of Strube's comments captivated my interest. She said that she tries to coax her students to write the stories that they would never tell their parents.

I am now a student in Cordelia's class, and I have to say that she's a wonderful and inspiring instructor. She offers each student helpful direction with their writing, she is patient and she is generous of spirit. I hope that she continues to write and teach for many years to come. I am grateful to her for her writing and her encouragement. Thank you Cordelia!

The Signature of All Things by Elizabeth Gilbert

The gift of a good book is my favourite thing. A book, carefully selected by an avid reader who has already enjoyed it, is the ultimate indulgence. Such was the cased when my friend Bev recently gave me The Signature of All Things by Elizabeth Gilbert.

Eat, Pray, Love was basically an exercise in frustration for me. I hated this novel because I found it formulaic, predictable and very simplistic. Coupled with the fact that everyone around me was raving about it, and despite trying many times, I just couldn't finish it. I gave up, and basically wrote the author off as a potboiler hack. (ok, so I have been known as a bit judgemental at times!)

The Signature of All Things is a fictional novel of a female botanist in the early 1800's.

Seeing each other regularly at our monthly book club, Bev and I have been friends for a few years now. We have enjoyed many books together, and I remember a particularly engaging discussion that flowed from our reading of I Shall Not Hate.


Signature was an epic novel, spanning the lives of both father and daughter botanists. It

Dickensian in nature, the reader is taken on a epic journey around the world over several decades.We are treated to an unhurried journey

There were a few parts that made me angry. Wanted to launch the book out the window during Alma's time in the cave in Tahiti...As though her activities there were really "all she ever wanted in her entire life..."  Please!!! Without giving it away, I will say that it's a pathetic weakness in Gilbert's writing to have positioned that scene as the pinnacle of Alma's life ambitions.  (For God's Sake, give me a break!!!)

The novel is unhurried. She takes her time to develop each character and build rich portraits.


That being said, I think this novel would have been improved with a critical editor, and an author who doesn't get bogged down in minutia.

It's a good read...but it's not epic.